LETTER TO THE EDITOR: Previous criticisms of columnist focused on wrong points
To the Editor:We are writing because, while we were angered by Matt Brown's dismissal of Brandeis and its reputation as "too Jewish for its own good," we feel that the essence of the problem with his argument was not addressed in the published letters in response ("Letters to the Editor," April 11 issue).
Brandeis' "Jewishness" is a result of the traditions upon which the university was founded-traditions of religious and cultural acceptance, in the admissions office and beyond, which were far from standard at the time of Brandeis' establishment. That these founding principles have resulted in Brandeis' continued reputation within the Jewish community should not be a problem, as long as we are delivering these promises to the rest of the student population as well.
Does Brown feel a lack of support for secular or non-Jewish religious organizations on campus? Are students of other religions discriminated against in the classroom, the playing field or the student government? If any of this is true, then yes, something does need to happen to bring us back to the policies of non-discrimination and social justice that constitute the Brandeis legacy.
If Brown and others like him feel overwhelmed by the Jewish majority, our responsibility as students and alumni alike should be to encourage Brandeis' growth and reputation in its other areas of strength and activity-its acclaimed professors, research opportunities, arts, cultural and community service organizations and social scene that bring in applicants from all cultural and religious backgrounds. But calling for a reduction or quieting of any segment of the student population is disturbing and absurd.
Encouraging Brandeis to become a more diverse campus has been a goal of the university's students and faculty for some time-one that, with every incoming class, becomes more of a reality. That many practicing Jews have found Brandeis to be one of the few college campuses where they can feel at home in no way prevents other students from feeling the same way. In our experience, it only provided an opportunity for learning and enrichment outside of the classroom as well as in it. We, a Jew and a Methodist, are proud of the unique tradition and principles of our alma mater and hope that they continue to live on in the actions and accomplishments of all Brandeis students.
And if it is so upsetting that spring break occasionally falls the week after your friends at University of Massachusetts are headed down to the Florida beaches, well, grow up.
-Danielle Friedman '04 and Sarah Orzalli '04
New York
Please note All comments are eligible for publication in The Justice.